TheCable

From frying pan to fire? In a bid to absolve itself of allegations on electoral misconduct, the Kano state government may have done more harm than good.

At a workshop organised by the Nigeria Union of Journalists (NUJ) in Kano on Monday, Mohammed Garba, commissioner for information, said videos and pictures of underage voters released recently were captured during the 2015 election, and not in the February 10 local government election as was insinuated.

The images went viral on social media immediately after the local government election, which was solely won by the All Progressives Congress (APC). The opposition had demanded a cancellation of the exercise, alleging irregularities.

CHALLENGES OF 2015

Garba admitted that underage voters took part in the last general election

But Garba said antagonists of the government were only raising a false alarm.

“The video that went viral in social media contained scenes where INEC card readers were deployed; and nothing of such was used in the last council poll in Kano — we did not use card readers, and there was no event of under-age voting during the 10 February council poll in Kano state,” he said.

“It was recorded during the last 30 March 2015 election… some mischievous persons are behind the spreading of the clips… that incident happened in 2015.”

INEC SAID IT HAD NO CONTROL BUT LATER SET UP A PANEL

When the news first broke, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) distanced itself, blaming it on the Kano State Independent Electoral Commission (KANSIEC).

“The commission wishes to inform the public that the images do not relate in any way to any election organised, conducted or superintended by INEC,” Oluwole Uzzi, INEC’s director, voter education and publicity, had said in a statement.

Mahmood Yakubu, chairman of INEC, needs to convince Nigerians that the commission is indeed prepared for the 2019 elections.

“As far as the commission can ascertain, they relate to a local government election conducted at the weekend, and over which we have no legal control or responsibility whatsoever. While the commission is charged with conducting elections at the state and national level, state electoral commissions are responsible for conducting the elections on the local government level.”

One week after that statement was issued, INEC set up a panel to probe the allegations, to which the state electoral commission responded by saying it would be vindicated.

THREAT TO LIFE OVER UNDERAGE VOTING

The issue of underage voting has been a challenge that we have been dealing with for a long time. In a recent interview with Punch, Lai Olurode, ex-national commissioner of INEC, narrated how declining underage voters almost cost him his life.

Olurode said community leaders presented a prepared list of children to INEC official and that he was opposed to it.

“I had to run for my life at one of the election centres in a part of the country because these people said children must vote or there would be no election at all. It is that bad,” Olurode had said.

Olurode

“When you see community leaders coming to meet you with a prepared list of children to be registered and you refuse, you come under threat. The APC government has a responsibility to deliver an election that will be better than that of 2015.”

PDP RAISED THE ALARM

In 2015, the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) raised the alarm on underage voting in some northern states but the APC asked Nigerians to ignore its opponent.

Uche Secondus, then deputy chairman of the PDP, had asked INEC to cancel the election results in seven states -Kano, Jigawa, Kaduna, Gombe, Bauchi, Katsina, Kogi – alleging that underage participated in the exercise.

“In Kano and some of these states in the north, majority of voters were under-aged. Voting also took place in the night and you know that in the night, rigging can take place. We have compiled our reports from Kano state chapter,” Secondus had said.

Accepting Secondus’ suggestion would have been disastrous as those states were the stronghold of the PDP opponent — President Muhammadu Buhari got 1,903,999 votes, his highest, from Kano but there were genuine fears which ought to have been addressed by INEC.

In the introductory section on pages 17 and 18 of Segun Adeniyi’s ‘Against the run of Play’, reference was made to a potential disparity of one million votes in the declared election results of Kano.

Adeniyi chronicled events on the 2015 election

Former President Goodluck Jonathan was quoted to have said: “Go and check the results from Kano. The presidential election and that of National Assembly happened on the same day and same time. The national assembly result reflected that about 800,000 people voted but that of the presidential election reflected a vote of about 1.8 million.”

MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF INEC REC

A lot of things appeared not to add up in that state. Just as allegations of rigging were making the rounds, reports filtered in that Minkaila Abdullahi, the resident electoral commissioner in the state, had died in a mysterious fire accident. Abdullahi died alongside his wife and two children, following an outbreak of fire at his official residence on Kashim Road, Nassarawa GRA in Kano. Up till date, the police have not made public their findings on the strange incident.

FIVE MILLION VOTES FROM WHERE?

There are fears of a repeat of these absurdities in the 2019 elections, especially with the promise of Abdullahi Ganduje, governor of Kano to secure five million votes for Buhari.

One of the images which attracted Garba’s denial. However, checks by TheCable showed that this particular picture surfaced online on February 11, 2018, a day after the Kano LG poll

A fact check done by TheCable showed that it is highly unlikely that 5 million people from Kano would vote for Buhari in 2019. Drawing statistics from the results of 1999, 2003, 2007, 2011 and 2015 presidential elections, TheCable found out that no presidential candidate has ever polled 5 million votes from a single state in Nigeria’s electoral history.

Perhaps Garba has an idea of how Ganduje can fulfil his promise or the governor was just being overzealous?

INEC has stated its preparedness for the next general election but there are issues to be addressed to avoid a situation where the credibility of the electoral body would be called to question. INEC must take drastic steps not just to address these misdeeds but to also redeem what critics have described as its “sinking” image.

Asking Garba to state the information he has on how underage voters partook in the election is a not a bad way to start. At least, that will help the commission to make necessary adjustments.